★★★★★
“Very nice to work with. They did an awesome job.”Ginger Smith Google / customer review
Customer Feedback From Real Roofing Projects
Magic Roofing Reviews
The best evidence comes from customers after the crew leaves. Read what local homeowners and property owners say about Magic Roofing’s workmanship, communication, responsiveness, cleanup and integrity.
- 4.5-Star Google Rating
- 95 Google Reviews
- BBB Accredited — A+ Rated
- Farmington-Based Since 2007
Google showed a 4.5-star rating from 95 reviews when checked on October 23, 2026. Ratings and review counts may change.
Qualified. Proven. Local.
Roofing credentials that matter
Google Business Profile Reviews
Roofing Customer Reviews in Farmington, NM
These are not generic testimonials written by a marketing department. They are customer comments connected to Magic Roofing’s public review history.
★★★★★
“Great service and the work was done as expected. Getting the quotes was not as quick as I expected but as soon as I called it was taken care of.”Karen Gray Google / customer review
★★★★★
“Great company, neat, and quick.”Paula Luther Google / customer review
★★★★★
“Even though my warranty had just expired Kevin still honored it and had his crew out immediately to fix my leak. Kevin did not have to do that, but he did and it shows he is a man of integrity.”Clint Alexander Google / customer review
★★★★★
“I was well cared for, serviced well before expected. I cannot stress enough the ease of obtaining a quote, leaving a deposit, and having the roof replaced within a month.”Jared Google / customer review
★★★★★
“Magic Roofing was the most reasonable quote of all that we received. They were on time, efficient, and the end product looks great. We appreciate their customer service.”Mark Pfetzer Google / customer review
★★★★★
“They got me a fair quote in a timely manner and completed the job ahead of schedule. I will definitely be using them again.”B&C Real Estate Solutions Google / customer review
★★★★★
“Four years after all the shingles were replaced, everything is flawless still. No problems whatsoever. They did an amazing job.”Jesse Kuzma Google / customer review
★★★★★
“If you need a new roof, Magic Roofing is the best roofing company to do the job. Very professional. I am very happy with the new roof they put on my home.”Jim Johnson Google / customer review
What This Service Covers
01
02
03
04
05
06
The Themes That Keep Showing Up
Individual projects differ, but customer feedback repeatedly points to the same service standards.
Professional Crews
Customers describe team members as professional, personable and easy to work with.
Efficient Production
Multiple reviews mention timely scheduling, fast installation and work completed ahead of expectations.
Clean Job Sites
Cleanup and leaving the property orderly are repeatedly called out as part of the experience.
Straightforward Estimates
Customers mention reasonable pricing, fair quotes and an easy process from estimate through deposit.
Workmanship That Holds Up
Long-term reviews describe completed roofs continuing to perform years after installation.
Integrity After Installation
Warranty follow-through and responsiveness after project completion appear in customer feedback.
Proof Beyond The Star Rating
A Reputation Built on Completed Work
Magic Roofing has served the region since 2007 with licensed residential, commercial and specialty roofing capability.
Licensed & Insured
New Mexico contractor license #364022.
BBB A+ Rated
BBB Accredited with a long-standing regional business profile.
Experienced Team
More than 150 years of combined roofing experience across the organization.
Straight Answers
Frequently Asked Questions
Are these reviews from Google?
The review section uses customer feedback presented through Magic Roofing’s public Google review information and existing site review feed.
Why include a review that mentions a slower quote?
Because credible reviews are not sanitized advertisements. That customer also explained the issue was handled after calling and that the work met expectations.
Does Magic Roofing respond to warranty concerns?
Customer feedback includes an example of Kevin honoring and addressing a leak immediately even though the warranty had just expired. Specific warranty coverage depends on the project documents.
Can I leave Magic Roofing a review?
Yes. Use Magic Roofing’s Google Business Profile to post an honest review of your experience.
What services do reviewers mention?
Reviews discuss full shingle replacement, leak work, flashing, vents, tile work, estimates, cleanup and long-term roof performance.
Start With A Clear Next Step
Ready to Work With a Roofing Company Customers Recommend?
Request an estimate or speak directly with the Farmington team about your roofing project.